In this post, we are providing with Essay on The Need for Reform in the collegium system for UPSC, SSC, Banking and other competitive exams.
Table of Contents
Essay on The Need for Reform in the collegium system
The collegium system in India is a system of appointment of judges to higher judiciary, comprising the Supreme Court and High Courts. Under this system, judges are appointed by a collegium consisting of the Chief Justice of India and a few senior judges. The system was introduced as an alternative to the earlier executive-led appointment system, which was criticized for being susceptible to political influence and favoritism. However, the collegium system has also faced criticism for lack of transparency, accountability, and diversity.
One of the major concerns with the collegium system is the lack of transparency in the appointment process. The decision-making process of the collegium is not transparent and there is no mechanism to evaluate the suitability of the candidates. The system of appointment is based on subjective opinions, which can lead to the appointment of judges who may not be the most qualified or suitable for the position.
Another criticism of the collegium system is the lack of accountability. The collegium is not answerable to any authority, and there is no mechanism to review the decisions made by the collegium. This lack of accountability can lead to decisions that are not in the best interest of the judiciary or the country.
The collegium system has also been criticized for lack of diversity. The system does not have any provision for affirmative action, which can lead to underrepresentation of marginalized communities. The lack of diversity can also lead to a lack of representation of diverse perspectives in the judiciary.
In recent years, there have been several calls for reform of the collegium system. One of the proposed reforms is to establish a transparent and objective process for appointment of judges. This can include the establishment of a Judicial Appointments Commission, which can evaluate the suitability of candidates based on objective criteria such as experience, knowledge, and integrity.
Another proposed reform is to increase the accountability of the collegium. This can include the establishment of a mechanism for review of decisions made by the collegium. The review mechanism can be established by an independent body, which can evaluate the decisions made by the collegium and provide feedback on the same.
Lastly, there have been calls to increase diversity in the judiciary. This can include the establishment of affirmative action policies, which can ensure representation of marginalized communities in the judiciary.
In conclusion, the collegium system in India has been criticized for lack of transparency, accountability, and diversity. There is a need for reform in the system to ensure that the appointment of judges is based on objective criteria, and the decisions made by the collegium are accountable and diverse. The proposed reforms can help strengthen the judiciary and ensure that it remains independent and impartial.
Have You Downloaded Our App?
Get Courses & Test-series at Affordable Prices
Short essay on The Need for Reform in the Collegium system
The collegium system in India is a system of appointing judges to the higher judiciary, comprising the Supreme Court and High Courts. It is a system where judges are appointed by a collegium consisting of the Chief Justice of India and senior judges. However, the collegium system has faced criticism for lack of transparency, accountability, and diversity, which has led to the need for reform in the system.
One of the significant criticisms of the collegium system is its lack of transparency. The appointment process is not transparent, and there is no mechanism to evaluate the suitability of the candidates. The decision-making process of the collegium is subjective, which can lead to the appointment of judges who may not be the most qualified or suitable for the position.
The collegium system has also been criticized for its lack of accountability. The collegium is not answerable to any authority, and there is no mechanism to review the decisions made by the collegium. This lack of accountability can lead to decisions that are not in the best interest of the judiciary or the country.
Another criticism of the collegium system is the lack of diversity. The system does not have any provision for affirmative action, which can lead to underrepresentation of marginalized communities. The lack of diversity can also lead to a lack of representation of diverse perspectives in the judiciary.
There have been calls for reform of the collegium system in recent years. One of the proposed reforms is to establish a transparent and objective process for appointment of judges. This can include the establishment of a Judicial Appointments Commission, which can evaluate the suitability of candidates based on objective criteria such as experience, knowledge, and integrity.
Another proposed reform is to increase the accountability of the collegium. This can include the establishment of a mechanism for review of decisions made by the collegium. The review mechanism can be established by an independent body, which can evaluate the decisions made by the collegium and provide feedback on the same.
Lastly, there have been calls to increase diversity in the judiciary. This can include the establishment of affirmative action policies, which can ensure representation of marginalized communities in the judiciary.
In conclusion, the collegium system in India has been criticized for lack of transparency, accountability, and diversity. There is a need for reform in the system to ensure that the appointment of judges is based on objective criteria, and the decisions made by the collegium are accountable and diverse. The proposed reforms can help strengthen the judiciary and ensure that it remains independent and impartial.
Clear Your Concepts
With
Free Videos
FAQ: Essay on The Need for Reform in the Collegium system
how to write a beautiful essay on The Need for Reform in the Collegium system?
To write a beautiful essay on the need for reform in the Collegium system, it is important to understand the key points that need to be covered. Here are some tips on how to write a beautiful essay on this topic:
Begin with an introduction that explains what the Collegium system is and why it is important. You can also mention some of the key criticisms of the system to set the stage for your argument.
Use examples and evidence to support your arguments. For example, you could cite specific cases where the Collegium system has led to controversial appointments or decisions, or where it has failed to ensure diversity in the judiciary.
Make sure to address the counterarguments. Acknowledge any potential weaknesses or challenges to your argument, but explain why you believe your proposed reforms are still necessary and effective.
Use language that is clear, concise, and persuasive. Avoid using overly technical or complicated language, and focus on making your arguments as accessible and understandable as possible.
End with a strong conclusion that summarizes your key points and restates your argument in a compelling way. You can also leave the reader with a thought-provoking question or call to action to encourage further reflection and engagement with the issue.
By following these tips, you can write a beautiful essay on the need for reform in the Collegium system that is engaging, persuasive, and informative. Remember to always stay focused on the main argument and use evidence and examples to support your points.
To Download the file Click on the Ads Below